ext_20885: (Default)
David Newgreen ([identity profile] 4thofeleven.livejournal.com) wrote in [community profile] b5_revisited 2009-02-24 05:50 am (UTC)

Hey, we’re getting into the good stuff now!

- There’s a fair number of aliens at the Centauri ceremony – including at least one Narn. League ambassadors, civilians just there for a free meal, or did the Centauri dominance of the region give their religion a chance to aquire at least a few followers among their former subject peoples?

- The Centauri god of the underworld is also protector of front doors? Interesting – presumably a god of liminality, then, like Hermes or Janus.

- Of all the characters who left the show, I think Na’toth is the one I most wish had stayed on. She gets a great introduction here, and I’d really liked to have seen her as a more level-headed assistant to G’kar during the rest of the series.

- G’kar can breathe unaided in n’grath’s quarters – I think this is the only time his ‘gill implants’ from the pilot are even obliquely mentioned.

- G’kar swapping the fruit he’s given is one of my favourite jokes in the whole series.

- The Narn don’t seem to have organised a ceremony. Could be it already happened, or G’kar cancelled it so he could focus on avoiding assassins. Could just be the Narn religion is meant to be private – though G’kar seems pretty casual about lending the Book of G’Quan to Garibaldi later on. Could be the Narn aren’t generally religious – either G’kar’s somewhat unusual among Narn, or that they tend to consider their beliefs more philosophies than religions. We never really get a good idea of how common followers of G'Quan are among the greater Narn population - though there only seems to be a couple on station in "By Any Means Necessary", and Na'Toth isn't religious.

- On the subject of characters who left the show, I’ve always felt that had Sinclair stayed on, and assuming Sakai would have ended up with the Anna Sheridan plot – a reasonable assumption – well, that’d be pretty damn depressing to watch, yes? I mean, the return of (shadow)Anna isn’t too bad, because it’s pretty obvious what’s going on, and we never really knew the original – but if it was the return of a character we knew and who I at least rather liked… Plus, it’d cast something of a pall over a Sinclair/Delenn relationship if it was starting with Sakai only recently missing. I think at least as far as this story thread is concerned, things worked out for the best.

- The ending is great – though, as people have pointed out, it does stretch credulity that Earth organised the festival without first giving Sinclair some pretty clear guidelines on how human religions should be represented. A little odd that Sinclair refers to one of the representatives as simply ‘an Aborigine’, rather than by the specific tribe he belongs to…

Post a comment in response:

This account has disabled anonymous posting.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org